After decades of building companies, mentoring founders, and witnessing both spectacular successes and failures, I've learned one thing: Entrepreneurial judgment isn't developed by creating a great pitch deck, writing a business plan, or formulating strategies. It's developed by confronting the realities of execution.
And I worry that AI is enabling entrepreneurs to bypass precisely the experiences that would make them better at it, with different consequences depending on where they are in their journey.
First-time founder: Projected competence without experience.
I’ve seen college students, and other first-time founders, armed with an idea and an AI subscription, create a product technical design, generate a great pitch deck, an impressive business plan, market analysis, financial model, and go-to-market strategy in a couple of days. But when they attempted to get past that stage to get their company off the ground, everything went sideways.
What they didn’t have was the judgment to recognize what was missing, or the difference between possible and probable. They never experienced sitting in front of an investment committee with someone like me on it who understands technology and points out the major holes in their design, or an experienced product manager who understands consumers and knows they will reject what the entrepreneur is certain they want, or investors who will dismantle their assumptions, and above all, the operational realities that make an elegant strategy unworkable no matter how tight the pitch deck is. What got them in trouble wasn’t that AI gave them bad answers. It's that they haven't developed the ability to distinguish good answers from bad ones.
They acquired the appearance of competence without going through the process of developing it.
Founder in the works: Experience without discipline.
I am seeing them more often these days. Entrepreneurs who have been through enough to know better. Ones who’ve made the mistakes, had their assumptions challenged, lost customers, missed forecasts, and learned why details matter. And yet, lured by the seductive shortcut AI offers, forget the lessons. They stop examining the underlying assumptions because the analysis looks reasonable. They accept recommendations without reconstructing the logic. They skip validation steps they once considered essential because the AI-generated strategy appears comprehensive. And things start going sideways! The irony of it all is that their experience makes them more vulnerable. They recognize enough of the answer to feel comfortable with it but no longer exercise the discipline to examine what's missing.
They're not losing their knowledge. They're losing the habits that made that knowledge valuable.
Seasoned founder: Wisdom without transfer.
My old boss in the military used to remind me that the difference between cocky and arrogant pilots is that the cocky ones are still alive. Those who survived the experience of the journey from having an idea to building a real living breathing company have developed something that cannot be acquired by reading a business plan: judgment shaped by accountability for real decisions and their consequences. I’ve survived that journey, and have the scars to prove it, a few times myself and I know the rules of the road: Trust no single source, including yourself; Question your assumptions; Recognize patterns; Ask uncomfortable questions; don’t confuse visions with hallucinations, and most certainly know the difference between cocky and arrogant. That’s how we sense that something is wrong before we can articulate why.
But experience comes with another responsibility: developing the judgment of those who will follow us. I am a very frustrating CEO/Founder to work with. I follow the 20-60-20 model. I push hard at the beginning, but, once we develop the first 20% of any strategy or product design, I delegate authority to align with responsibilities and seniority and expect my team’s decisions for the 60% to be based on clear reasoning, vigorously debated regardless of owner, with tolerances for uncertainty, and contingency plans to account for the occasional, but unavoidable failure behind those decisions, when I re-engage for the last 20 percent. Even when I have the answer or know a short cut during the 60% process, I expect the team to do the work. I view that approach and the lessons my team learns, painful and slow as it may be at times, as an essential leadership responsibility.
Unfortunately, I see experienced founders who skip that part. Instead of asking the team to do the work, they use their knowledge to ask the AI for outputs and hand their teams instructions to execute. That eventually produces teams that can execute increasingly sophisticated instructions without developing the ability to question them. And that is crossing over into arrogance.
They're leveraging their experience without transferring their wisdom.
And that may be the most damaging consequence of all.
I'm not arguing against AI. I use it extensively and consider it one of the most powerful productivity tools I've encountered. I’ve used it to edit and critique what I thought was my final version of this, and boy, did it! But productivity and capability are not the same thing. The difficult conversations, failed assumptions, rejected proposals, and uncomfortable decisions aren't just obstacles to overcome on the journey to becoming a capable entrepreneur. They're how entrepreneurial judgment is developed.
AI can eliminate unnecessary friction. It can accelerate analysis, challenge assumptions, and improve execution. But we need to distinguish between friction that wastes time and friction that develops capability.
The real risk isn't that AI will replace entrepreneurs.
It's that we'll produce founders who can articulate strategies they don't understand, leaders who no longer question what looks reasonable, and experienced entrepreneurs who fail to develop the next generation.
The ultimate test of an entrepreneur isn't the quality of the plan they can produce. It's the quality of the decisions they make when reality refuses to follow it.
Chuck Papageorgiou is Chief Executive Officer of NeuroEM Therapeutics, a clinical stage biotechnology company developing technologies designed to support brain health and address cognitive decline associated with aging and neurodegenerative disease.
A seasoned executive, entrepreneur, and enterprise technologist, Chuck brings more than two decades of experience leading business transformation, organizational turnarounds, mergers and acquisitions, technology strategy, and startup growth. He has led organizations ranging from early stage companies to global operations with more than 10,000 employees and has advised on major restructuring and M&A transactions across multiple industries.



